Conversation
anyone got religion recommendations im trying to figure out how to feel a sense of meaning again
7
0
1
@salt sorry but rum is the joy of all lizzies. also pork. also gummies. and premarital sex. i gotta have those things
1
0
2
@haematophage to Allah, it is far better to be a sinful muslim than not a muslim
1
0
0
@haematophage converting to a religion to fill a void in your life is like doing the same thing with dating (it'll end badly in both cases and be a huge waste of time)
2
1
4
@salt sorry if im gonna be doing an abrahamic religion it's anglicanism
1
0
1
@haematophage that's okay. if i can just ask you to do something. because for a while i thought like this too. so could you just look into the scientific miracles in the quran? at worst it will just be interesting, and in my opinion they provide very strong evidence for the truth of islam.
1
0
0
@salt no, sorry, if Jesus wasn't a madman or a con artist he was absolutely God and im not trusting some backwater desert Joseph Smith-ass "i swear bro an angel revealed it to me and uhh no you can't see it" child rapist
2
0
1
@haematophage holy shit i forgot how fucking psychotic white people are about islam for a moment
1
0
5
@nyx dont care didnt ask plus i dont like your superiority complex
2
0
0
@haematophage you literally did ask in the OP and I gave some genuine advice. try not lashing out at people for no reason right after posting weird Islamophobic shit
1
0
6
@haematophage @nyx this is the most heated ive seen this place in awhile
0
0
0
@haematophage just spend your whole life rapidly alternating between declaring that all religion should be banned and their evangelists shot, and praying begging for jesus' forgiveness like i do (plus lowkey wishing i was KKKatholic instead of CofE)
0
2
3
@nyx islamophobia is when you think having sex with a 9 year old is bad and think that Islam and Mormonism are obviously bad fanfics
2
0
1
@haematophage this is more a problem with patriarchal civilizations in general than with Islam specifically. for most of human history until like the early/mid 20th century it was unfortunately extremely common for children and teenagers to get married off to older men
1
0
1
@nyx and you'll notice that nowhere did i say that having sex with nine year olds was something only muslims did. However, only one major world religion has a prophet who did in fact according to their own traditions have sex with a nine year old girl. If finding that intolerable is "Islamophobic" then by golly I guess I am.
3
0
0
@haematophage @nyx what do you think the bible says on how to enforce rape laws, exactly
0
0
2
@haematophage I think this probably has more to do with the fact that Muhammad wasn't celibate, unlike Jesus. I would imagine there are plenty of references to important figures in the Old Testament for instance having child brides. I don't think it's a good thing, quite the contrary, but I think it's weird to focus on this specifically about Islam because it's a pretty common far-right dogwhistle and you getting more defensive about it only makes it weirder that you're choosing to die on this hill when like I said this is unfortunately a pretty universal thing in the ancient world unless you were literally celibate like Jesus lmao
2
0
3
@haematophage @nyx Islam sucks in a lot of ways but Sufism is hella cool
1
0
0
@georgia @nyx oh it's definitely cool i think there's lots of interesting theology but i would never practice it because i have a mountain of moral and logical objections to it
0
0
1
@haematophage it's not any worse in these respects than every other patriarchal religion because the root of pedophilia is patriarchy and has nothing to do with which region of the world it happens in.
1
0
3
@nyx i dont actually care. muhammad raped a nine year old, therefore i could never be muslim because i think a religion founded by a rapist of nine year old girls is that claims said rapist of nine year old girls is actually the most holy man to ever exist is inherently flawed.
1
0
0
@haematophage I mean that's fair and a respectable opinion to have but I think that this requires ruling out every "Abrahamic" religion as condoning child rape. which to be fair, I think is kind of a correct assessment of them and every other patriarchal religion, which is related to why I don't follow one myself.
1
0
2
@haematophage i like some ancient greek myth. its nice being able to pick and choose specific gods to worship and seek favour with based around their specialisations and having them not actually be invisible forces and actually quite visible in reality as mostly just personifications of natural and cultural phenomena

idk just easier to get into when theres some tangibility involved and it doesnt impose any particular set of morals (nor intends to do that)
1
0
2
@haematophage then again one of the ones i worship is a somnophile so yknow
1
0
2
@nyx okay so did you just want to lecture me about trying not to offend people's feelings or did you just want to be contrarian for no fucking reason
1
0
0
@haematophage honestly I've already made my point multiple times in this thread that the problem is that patriarchy in general condones child rape, and that this is hardly a problem specific to Islam, so it's weird to focus on that specifically about it. if you want to reject all patriarchal religions on this basis, then fine, I am in agreement with you on that, but it's a racist bad faith argument to act like Islam is even remotely unique in this respect. and with that I'm muting this thread because I've put up with enough of you lashing out at me for trying to have a good faith discussion here
0
0
2

@salt @haematophage racism ? in my religion thread ? more likely than u think

1
0
3

@haematophage @salt no yea im not biting not today today i am at peace with the world and no bait shall make me reconsider

0
0
6
@nyx @haematophage it's also a misunderstanding of why anyone would believe that information

if you do the math based on the timeline of events then aisha would be 16-19 but there is a curious bit of historical context where people wanted to stress how "pure" she was and leave no doubts about it, so through a game of telephone they somehow managed to shave off a decade from the timeline and didn't see a problem with that because of the time period. funnily enough no one ever bothered to fix the discrepancy with her sister's age relative to the timeline -- she is known to be 10 years older but timeline-wise she would have to be 20 years older. easy mistake to make when you don't keep birth records

https://www.quran-islam.org/articles/part_5/age_of_aisha_%28P1472%29.html

speaking of keeping records, for like 200 years there was a culture of expressly *not* keeping records about the prophet muhammad due to aniconism, although oral traditions survived. (it's these oral traditions that form the basis of supplemental beliefs for many muslims even though there is nothing justifying it in the text of the quran)

https://www.quran-islam.org/articles/part_5/did_muhammad_authorise_his_sunna_(P1482).html
0
0
0
@nyx @haematophage confirming by personal experience (and it occurs to me the timing in my case actually lines up really well for this comparison)
0
0
0
@coolbean @haematophage what's wrong with that i like sleeping too

::looks up a thing real quick::

ohno
1
0
1
@coolbean @haematophage (this isn't even entirely a shitpost i'm so used to stories about "ancient slumbering gods" that i actually got confused for a moment)
1
0
1
@apophis @haematophage haha yeae

shits fucked, like theres literally nothing else i can say about what shes done to endymion. the moon is a rapist
1
0
1
@coolbean @haematophage
> what she's done
> moon

::looks up a thing real quick::

[bart-no-what-sorryforceofhabit_zeus.jpg]
1
0
0
the actual story
Show content
@apophis @haematophage oh you havent even looked up the story? haha

well, the moon is always there as we sleep is it not? kinda creepy and perfectly valid characterisation for a moon goddess

then she got obsessed with a specific mortal she found so much more beautiful than all the others, so she did the only reasonable thing and cursed him with an eternal sleep to prevent him eventually aging and dying, then having multiple children with him

honestly remind me why i worship her and not her sister eos? besides lillian's moon obsession
0
0
1