@georgia @sathariel /hj
im pretty pauline in my outlook on the law but usually if i were to cite an example i would cite jesus. imo the christian perspective on law is consistent, just weird. like, Jesus refers to something in the torah as falsely elevated human tradition and paul had a man get circumcised. i think this is cause to try to figure out what the consistent line is.
similarly, the apostles did not break from kosher in their dietary habits.
i like the description of antinomian nomianism. the true law is the law of love, but we may adopt rules to exercise it. paul’s perspective specifically was that christianity did not dissolve God’s covenant with the Jewish people but did not require entry into it either (which is why the council of jerusalem concluded that while jewish christians should keep the law, gentile converts had pretty minimal rules). coming out of that jewish tradition, to center any rules as a goal rather than as a means of seeking God is to make them not only worthless but a poison.
especially from a protestant reading, the law is considered actually impossible to follow (eg if you look with lust then you have already committed adultery). as written the law is a partial aiming at the Law (love). it convicts so that we might have understanding of our own sin. it brings death but this isnt considered bad bc in a sense the evil was already there. my best understanding of paul is that law gives sin form so that we might be freed from it.
@georgia @sathariel tl;dr when Jesus spoke highly of the law it probably wasnt the law as most of His audience would have understood and on the flipside what seems like paul holding the law in low regard (despite following it himself) is him speaking highly of the role he understands it to play
@georgia @sathariel i dont read much at all tbh 🥀
@georgia @sathariel i pray very frequently but my formal prayer practice (aside from sunday eucharist obv) is centered on the daily office. i do find that this has brought me a lot closer to God (which is not a matter of knowledge) but also taught me a lot
@georgia @sathariel even just praying the lord’s prayer daily has taught me a lot. a lot of my thoughts on love as th presence of God comes from “thy kingdom come, thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven” and my description of God as a great sea of infinite care comes from “forgive us our sins/debts/trespasses as we forgive those who sin/tresspass against us/our debtors” (translation is fun)
@lizzie @georgia @sathariel
When y’all say “law” you mean the laws of a country or like the commandments?
@georgia @sathariel > divine mercy more than divine justice
same thing oomf
i suppose one could reasonably concieve of Him as a lawgiver. most of his teachings have pretty clear active practice! but the core idea is that He is the law
@raccoon @georgia @sathariel law and socially negotiated morals as a whole phenomenon but especially the commandments
@georgia @sathariel more was and is prohibited if it distresses your siblings
@georgia @sathariel i prefer the just to the lesser. he honestly comes up way more
that being said, greater/lesser is a reference to age and height not importance
@georgia @sathariel james the big and james the small
@georgia @sathariel i found this out like two minutes ago looking at wikipedia 😭
@salt @georgia @sathariel apparently he is sometimes even called “james the little” in english
@salt @georgia @sathariel oh. probably at least when it comes from old translations
@technicallydifficult @georgia @sathariel it really does feel like a downgrade yeah. makes God feel so cold
@technicallydifficult @georgia @sathariel it kinda reminds me of what i saw from the new calvinists where mercy is just a tyrannical God’s aura farming rather than truly patient and overwhelmingly abundant
@waypastfuture @georgia @sathariel i agree that the letter that kills crucifies christ yeah
@technicallydifficult @waypastfuture @georgia @sathariel this is kinda augustine-pilled. his method is pretty much “if your reading of scripture doesnt lead you into greater love for God and your neighbor, youre reading it wrong.”
or even that its better to misunderstand scripture to love than to correctly understand it for hatred
@waypastfuture @georgia @sathariel well, its complicated bc i think surrendering oneself to the letter crucifies christ but it itself doesnt bc as paul would argue in that very chapter (just reread it lmao), the law is good and holy exactly bc it brings death, not by being sin but by being a means by which sin operates and makes itself clear.
when writing my bits of this thread, i keep thinking of “O happy fault that earned so great, so glorious a redeemer!”
@KaiserKitty @waypastfuture @georgia @sathariel i mean, i don’t think the point of Him not doing that is that He needed to be crucified. i don’t think He’d have done that either way. thats exactly the power of this world that satan tempted Him with!
@technicallydifficult @georgia @sathariel @waypastfuture the apostles still didnt eat it except for the sake of hospitality. you are under no obligation to eat pork
@technicallydifficult @georgia @sathariel @waypastfuture rip i hope you can eat it with less guilt then