@oshy @anemone Pretty much
But I started with DS and I somewhat hated it. It really wasn't the SMB4 I wanted and then the series continued being rather unimpressive. I HAD to pick up the one on Wii U around when it released because there was NOTHING else. It was okay at best. I dunno if it's the best, but I feel like NSMBDS should've been "this good" from the get go
A kind of disappointing middle between retro and new bland. 3D Land and World were definitively more like it IMO. Wonder is the NSMB formula mastered, with a new gimmick that made it worth it. They also learned from the 3D World overworld and used it for Wonder, which is all the much better, as that type of overworld made way more sense than the crappy semi-retro map
Hilariously, Sonic has just caught up with NSMB with Sonic Superstar with the exact same issues without knowing how to properly modernise it so you're left with something alright but still an unsatisfying between between new and retro that doesn't seem to know what it wants to be